Is It Possible to Sleep Train Without Crying It Out? Yep—Here’s How|Your Zen Baby Sleep |Livingston

By: Sarah Bossio, Certified Pediatric Sleep Expert

You probably didn't dream of one day Googling "how to sleep train my baby without using cry-it-out," right? And yet, here we are—somewhat bleary-eyed, coffee in hand, just wanting a little peace at bedtime without turning into a sleep-deprived zombie. I see you. I've been there. And I'm here to tell you: You can teach your baby to sleep independently without tears (well, not many) and without ever feeling like you're abandoning them.

Let's talk about the Chair Method—a slow, supportive approach that leans on connection, not cries.

Cry It Out Isn't Your Only Option—Here's a Kinder Way to Sleep Train

I want to shout this from the rooftops: Sleep training does not have to mean leaving your baby in a room alone to cry for hours. That might work for some families, but it doesn't feel right for many—especially those who've been co-sleeping or rocking their little ones to sleep. And that's okay. That's where the Chair Method comes in. It's a gradual fading technique that keeps you close while your baby learns to fall asleep solo.

Instead of quick fixes or rigid rules, think of this as guiding your baby to sleep with patience, presence, and love.

First Things First: Is Your Baby Ready?

The magic sleep window usually opens around four months old. At that point, day and night start to align with your baby's internal clock as their circadian rhythm starts to take shape. Are you going to sleep train before then? It's possible that you're just making things harder for both you and your child. Let's hold off till the developmental benchmark is reached.

Once they're ready, your goal isn't to "fix" your baby's sleep—it's to teach it gently and in a way that respects both their needs and yours.

The Bedtime Routine Glow-Up: Ditch Drowsy and Do This Instead

Before you sit in the chair, let's get the sleep environment working for you—not against you.

Keep the nursery dark, but not cave dark. We want melatonin, not total blackout confusion.
Ditch the night lights and keep the crib clear—no bumpers, blankets, or stuffed animals.
Set the room temp between 68° and 72°F. Cosy, but not sweaty.
Use white or brown noise (no waves or lullabies, please) at around 50–75 dB.

Now, let's talk about the bedtime routine—your new BFF. Start it 30 minutes earlier than usual (even if that feels wild). Feed first, then bath if it's bath night, then PJs, books, snuggles. And the big twist? You're putting the baby in the crib completely awake. None of that "baby crib drowsy" business—it's a myth that backfires. Your baby needs to learn to fall asleep when they wake up. That's what builds security.

What Does the Chair Method Look Like?

Okay, you've done the routine. Baby's in the crib. Here's where the Chair Method gets real.

If your baby starts to cry? Sit. Right. Down.

Literally, in a chair you've pre-placed next to the crib, knees brushing the rail. You stay there until your baby falls asleep. You can offer touch—a hand on their belly or a gentle cheek rub. If touch makes them fussier, try soft words or singing. You can even co-breathe—your calm breaths help them calm down, too. (Science is wild, right?)

But here's the non-negotiable: No picking up. That confuses your baby and amps up the upset when you put them back down.

You stay with them. You're there. You're present. But you're not doing the sleep for them.

Gradual Fading 101: Slowly Step Back While Baby Steps Up

This is the heart of the Chair Method—you always show up but do a little less over time.

Days 1–3: Sit by the crib and offer comfort as needed.
Days 4–6: Move the chair to the middle of the room.
Days 7–9: Slide to the doorway.
Days 10+: Sit outside the door or switch to timed check-ins if that feels better.

This is gradually fading in action—you're still there, but the training wheels are coming off slowly. The baby is learning that sleep is safe, and they're capable, even without you an inch away.

When It Feels Hard - Here's What to Do.

Let's be honest: This process isn't all rainbows. Some babies cry more when you're in the room because they can see you and still don't get why you're not rocking or feeding them. That's normal. That's human.

If this happens and you feel like the Chair Method isn't the right fit, you're not failing. You're being attuned. Some families switch to time checks, and that's okay. You're allowed to pivot.

But this method brings the most peace for many, especially those transitioning from co-sleeping. You're still there. You're guiding, not leaving.

Stick With It: Why Consistency is the Real Secret Sauce

This isn't just a bedtime gig. If the baby wakes up at night, you return to your chair. It's the same for naps. You use the same routine, consistent routine, and level of support. Sleep training works when it's repeatable. When your child knows what to expect, they learn faster and feel safer.

Yes, nights get better before naps. And yes, early morning wakeups are the last to sort themselves out (babies are funny like that). But hang in there. You're building something powerful—trust and independence, all rolled into one.

You've Got This (and I've Got You)

This whole sleep training thing can feel overwhelming. I get it. But pushing your baby away isn't the goal of the Chair Method. It involves physically and emotionally sitting with them while they pick up new knowledge. Things's about showing them that they can accomplish things on their own even when you are teaching them.

This serves as a reminder that you are doing an excellent job. You must be quite concerned if you are reading this. And your baby feels that.

You don't have to go it alone. If you need guidance, have questions, or want to vent about that one brutal night—reach out. Let's walk this journey together, one small, sleepy step at a time.

From my living room to yours—sweet dreams, friend.

P.S. If this method has your name written all over it, comment below or book a quick call. I am always available to support you, troubleshoot, and celebrate your victories (such as the baby's first night's sleep!).

Watch Sleep Videos

Did you know? I also host a weekly Q&A on my Instagram. Tune in or send me a DM on the 'gram!

DM Me

I work with families one-on-one all the time who are experiencing issues with their babies' naps, overnight sleep, and more. If this sounds like you, please book a 15-minute sleep assessment call just so I can understand a little bit more about your child's sleep and then explain ways that I can work one-on-one with you to get it in order.

Book Your Free Discovery Call